About Goodville Mutual
Goodville Mutual Casualty Company was founded in 1926 in Goodville, Pennsylvania, by a small group of Mennonite men to write automobile liability insurance. The home office has been in New Holland since 1973. The company merged with Earl Mutual in 1988 and with three Mennonite-related mutual fire insurers in 1996, and it affiliated with German Mutual Insurance Company of Napoleon, Ohio, in 2013 and Reamstown Mutual Insurance Company in 2019.
Products
- Auto insurance
- Homeowners
- Farm coverage
- Business and church policies
- Umbrella liability
How to buy
Goodville works exclusively through independent agents and currently operates in eight states. It follows a socially responsible investment strategy.
Financial strength
The company holds an A (Excellent) rating, financial size category VIII, from AM Best.
Contact and claims
The home office is at 625 W Main Street, New Holland, PA 17557, open Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. ET. Call toll-free at 800-448-4622 or 717-354-4921. Claims can be reported 24/7. Visit the official website.